After serving as Vicar of the Parish for five years, Fr Graeme Drewery left for the Parish of Brotton in East Cleveland in 2005. In September of the same year, Fr Stephen Cooper was appointed Priest in Charge. On 1st January 2009, it was formally agreed that the Parishes of St John the Evangelist and St Columba be held in Plurality, and Fr Cooper was appointed Vicar.